Three black-and-white hands holding smartphones beneath colourful overlapping speech bubbles on a yellow background

PLEASE STOP CHANGING THE ALGORITHM

There was a time when social media felt relatively straightforward.
You made something good.
You posted it.
People who followed you had a reasonable chance of seeing it.
Lovely.
Then somebody invented the algorithm.
Actually, algorithms have always been there in one form or another. But somewhere along the way, they became the slightly unpredictable colleague nobody quite understands.
Post more Reels.
No, fewer Reels.
Carousels are back.
Put the link in the comments.
Never put the link in the comments.
Post at 7.42am on a Tuesday while standing on one leg.
And whatever you do, apparently, don’t use the wrong number of hashtags.
It can all become rather exhausting.
Especially for businesses trying to do social media properly.

THE RULES KEEP MOVING
The frustrating thing is that there is rarely one neat answer.
Social platforms are constantly adjusting what appears in our feeds, trying to work out what we’ll stop for, what we’ll watch, what we’ll share and what might keep us hanging around for another ten minutes.
Which means something that performed brilliantly six months ago can suddenly appear to have been shown to seventeen people and someone’s aunt.
It is very easy to respond by becoming obsessed with the mechanics.
What time did we post?
Was the caption too long?
Should that have been a Reel?
Did somebody use the word “link”?
And yes, those things can matter.
But they are not the most interesting question.
The more useful question is:
Was it worth stopping for?

MAYBE WE’VE BEEN ASKING THE WRONG THING
We spend quite a lot of time talking about social content with clients.
And increasingly, we’re trying to move away from:
“What do we need to post this week?”
Towards:
“What have we got that’s actually worth saying?”
That small change makes a surprisingly big difference.

Because nobody opens Instagram hoping to see another beautifully branded “Thirsty Thursday” graphic.
Nobody is waiting for your company to tell them it is National Something-or-Other Day unless you have a genuinely good reason to join in. And very few people are likely to stop because the content calendar said it was time for a product post.
People stop for interesting things.
A beautiful image.
A useful idea.
A strong opinion.
Something funny.
Something they didn’t know.
A person they want to hear from.
A glimpse behind a door they wouldn’t normally get through.
The algorithm may decide how far something travels.
But the idea still has to make somebody care in the first place.

THE HUMAN BIT IS GETTING MORE IMPORTANT
Oddly, while social media becomes increasingly driven by technology, the platforms themselves are beginning to talk more about authenticity. LinkedIn, for example, has been quite explicit about reducing generic content, engagement bait and automated conversations in favour of real voices and useful perspectives.
Which makes sense.
When everybody has access to the same tools, templates and trends, sounding like an actual human becomes quite a competitive advantage.
A slightly imperfect photograph from behind the scenes can sometimes do more than the beautifully art-directed campaign shot.
A chef saying something interesting can beat the polished brand caption.
A spontaneous Story can outperform the post that took three days to approve.
Not always.
But often enough to remind us that social media was meant to be social.

SO, DO WE IGNORE THE ALGORITHM?
Sadly, no.
We still need to understand what the platforms are doing.
We need to look at what people are watching, saving, sharing and responding to.
We need to test formats.
We need to know when a bit of paid support will help good content travel further.
And occasionally we will still find ourselves discussing whether something should be 9:16 or 4:5 with far more seriousness than feels reasonable.
But we don’t think the algorithm should be the creative director.
That job still belongs to people.

MAKE SOMETHING WORTH SEEING
Perhaps that is the simplest social strategy of all.
Know who you are talking to.
Have something interesting to say.
Say it like a human.
Make it useful, beautiful, funny, surprising or worth passing on.
And then give it the best chance you can.
The algorithm may love it.
The algorithm may completely ignore it.
The algorithm may change its mind again next Thursday.
But at least you won’t have bored everyone trying to please it.